Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches & Review

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches & Review

Aqua blues like Pretty Serious Pookie from The Well Meaning But Ultimately Quite Awkward Pet Names Collection are flattering on virtually everyone. It looks fresh, suits any season, and the no-nonsense formula is versatile.

Cloudless skies. Frosty icicles. Pretty Serious Pookie fits into any design you want to paint!

The classic Madonna song, True Blue initially sprung to mind when I first laid eyes on this aqua.

When I was a kid, my dad used to play that song a lot (when he wasn’t spinning Elvis Presley tracks. And, yes, we had a record player. My dad was a big music and movie fan.)

Although none of my friends cared for the movie, the first time my dad introduced me to Madonna, in the film Who’s That Girl, I found it really entertaining. Haven’t seen it since I was maybe 5-years-old, so I’ll probably have to check it out soon.

Now as an unfortunate “grown-up,” my perspective on the movie probably is so different. It will be interesting to see if it still appeals to me. (Some films, like Return to Oz and The Goonies still remain favourites from childhood into adulthood, though. Great movies transcend age.)

I remember asking my dad to play Who’s That Girl again when the credits started rolling at the end of the movie. Haha, apparently when I liked a movie, I would watch it back-to-back and butcher it. 😉

My dad also had some of Madonna’s early concerts on VHS tape. We would watch it together, and innocent l’il me once asked my dad why Madonna wore Dixie cups. I can’t remember what his response was (haha, it’s really too bad!), but as a kid, I truly felt sorry for her and thought that she didn’t have enough money for real clothes. As an adult now, don’t worry – I understand. Still, I wish I could go back to those days of innocence.

Pretty Serious Pookie Pictures

Pretty Serious Pookie Review

Artificial Light

Pretty Serious Cosmetics Pookie Swatch

Natural Light

Pretty Serious Pet Names Collection Pookie Review

Artificial Light

Pretty Serious Pookie Review Pictures

Natural Light

Pookie by Pretty Serious Cosmetics

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches

All swatches have:

    • OPI Nail Envy Nail Strengthener – Maintenance version (Used as a base coat)
    • 2 coats of Pretty Serious Pookie
    • Pretty Serious Aqua Coat Top Coat (Provided by Pretty Serious Cosmetics.)

Artificial Light Photos

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches & Review

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatch & Review

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatch

Natural Light Photos

Pretty Serious Pookie Review & Swatches

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches Swatch Review

Pretty Serious Pookie Swatch Pet Names Collection Swatches

Pookie by Pretty Serious Cosmetics


  • Aqua blue creme (Yes)

Key Notes

  • Name: Pretty Serious Pookie
  • Collection: Pretty Serious The Well Meaning But Ultimately Quite Awkward Pet Names Collection 2015
  • Colours Available in the Collection: Cuddle Bunny, Honey Puff, Pookie, Snugglebutt, Stud Muffin, Sugar Cakes, Baron Von Bootiful, Darkling Squishy, Gloomy Kitty & Pumpkin Head
  • Amount: 11 mL (0.37 fl. oz.)
  • Retail Price: $9.95 AUD
  • Disclosure: This was provided as a press sample by Pretty Serious Cosmetics.
  • Where to Buy: Pretty Serious website & stockists

Pretty Serious Pookie Review


Pookie by Pretty Serious is a vibrant aqua that isn’t too bright – it’s like a blue for Goldilocks’ baby bear because it’s “just right.”

A shade like this has just enough punch that I feel it would look wonderful on a wide range of skin tones from fair to rich.

It’s exactly the kind of shade that, each time I sport it, I can’t help but admire my manicure like a polish peacock! 😉


While I used to be drawn to glitter and crazy finishes when I was younger, I find that the older I get, cremes are becoming more appealing to me. Not only does the finish look so polished and smooth, but cremes are easy to wear solo or as a base for nail art. It also allows the colour to be the star of the show, which I appreciate.

When it comes time to remove it, it comes off without any hassles, which is also a wonderful benefit.

Application & Formula

The application is what dreams are made of! Pookie by Pretty Serious is smooth, pigmented, and exceptionally creamy!

With only two coats, I was able to get the full coverage that you see in the photos above.

I tend to use medium coats, but with this saturated formula, I think that even if you use thin coats, you’ll still be able to achieve full opacity. Great formula!


Those who are making conscious shopping choices will be thrilled to know that Pretty Serious Pookie doesn’t contain Formaldehyde, Formaldehyde Resin, DBP, or Toluene.


This nail polish is vegan and cruelty-free, which I think is especially appropriate because this collection is about pets! 🙂


  • Flattering aqua creme for many different skin tones
  • Creamy & smooth
  • Pigmented & needs just 2 coats for full coverage
  • No Formaldehyde, Formaldehyde Resin, DBP, or Toluene
  • Vegan & cruelty-free


  • Not a crazy shade (But not every colour needs to be admitted into the insane asylum…)

Final Verdict: 9.5/10

I’m a big fan of Pretty Serious Pookie because the colour is so cheerful, and the formula is easy to paint with.

This is one of the better creamy and pigmented aquas that I’ve worn. So beautiful!

Are you ‘guilty’ of calling a loved one Pookie? Do you remember Madonna’s movie, Who’s That Girl? What is your favourite Madonna song of all time?


4 thoughts on “Pretty Serious Pookie Swatches & Review

  1. Melissa

    What a gorgeous color! I’m really loving this one. I think I’m going to have to buy this polish. It’s calling my name. LOL As always it looks amazing on you Mary.

    1. Mary S. Post author

      Hey Melissa!

      The opacity, cheerful colour, and excellent formula make this polish a winner! I have no doubt you’re going to get a lot of use out of it!

    1. Mary S. Post author

      Hey Sasha!

      Hehe, so it has a sentimental reason for you! You NEED this polish then, and you can paint your daughter’s nails with it, too! 😉


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge